Author / Post |
|
sevarg Lifetime Site Supporter
Passed Away 2016
|
Joined: December/16/2003 United States Posts: 4698 IP Logged
|
Posted: April/16/2008 at 4:39pm |
Quote
|
|
I am still using NiCads because they are so reliable, and predictable. However, on all my large aircraft I use a power distribution system that uses two 5-cell 1800 ma packs. It alternates current draw between the two packs so that they discharge at the same rate. If one pack fails, then the system uses the other pack. It provides filter 6 Volts to the servos, and filtered, regulated 5 volts to the receiver. Any high drain spikes from the servos is filtered out before they can ever get to the receiver. I have flown 8 10-15 minutes flights and still had plenty of reserve power. My transmitter usually needs charging before the flight packs do.
__________________ Flying:
BUSA 1/3 Pup
GeeBee Sportster
Canadair 215 Water Bomber
BUSA 1/3 Nieuport 28
Thomas repair:1/4 Beech Starship
Repairing: 40% Cessna U3-B
Building:Kawasaki Ki-100 110"
NEXT:NorthropXB35
|
Back to Top Printer Friendly Version Profile
Search
|
|
|
103/17 Basic Member
|
Joined: September/11/2006 United States Posts: 89 IP Logged
|
Posted: June/09/2008 at 2:43pm |
Quote
|
|
I have switched all of my planes to 1650 AA Nickel metal's. They are the best bang for the buck for me. I have them in all my planes, I buy them from Dave Thacker at Radical R/C........ Dave's got the best prices and outstanding service, A+. Hes top shelf to deal with and I get them in two days. They are as reliable as any nicad I have ever used in 25 years of flying........
103/17
|
Back to Top Printer Friendly Version Profile
Search
Web
|
|
|
Mode 1 Basic Member
|
Joined: February/13/2007 United States Posts: 89 IP Logged
|
Posted: July/22/2008 at 6:19am |
Quote
|
|
I feel the same way as Sevarg about NiCads, they are the old and reliable technology. NiCads are tough as nails, something I want in an airborne pack. They are less likely to sustain damage by being overcharged and don't loose as much charge sitting idle. i am liking what I hear about A123s and look forward to hearing more.
__________________ Building Model Airplanes is just "PLANE FUN!"
|
Back to Top Printer Friendly Version Profile
Search
|
|
|
HellcatAce Basic Member
Zero Killer
|
Joined: October/13/2005 United States Posts: 42 IP Logged
|
Posted: August/18/2008 at 3:47pm |
Quote
|
|
I use mostly NiMh packs for my planes. For my bigger stuff I use two 5 cell 6v 2000 mah packs. No fancy distribution stuff , just in a spare channel with it's own switch. Not that there's anything wrong with the big regulator and battery sharing devices, it's just that it turns into another single point of failure.
For the smaller stuff, which is the bulk of my squadron in the hangar, I use 4.8v NiMh packs ranging from 1650 mah to 2700 mah. I love that I can just put them on peak charge if I decide to go fly at the last minute without worrying about NiCd memory issues. Since I'm already running on nominal voltage, no regulator is needed and I enjoy many flights without the need to recharge.
I have also been moving to NiMh for my transmitters as well. With the longer charge capacity of the receiver packs, I figured I better have the radio last as long so I don't need to field charge, though with these packs it's no big deal. I just plug them in and hit Peak Charge and watch some flying from a nice comfy seat knowing my next flight will be in just a few minutes.
__________________ Don't try and argue with an Idiot. They just drag you down to their level and beat you with experience!
|
Back to Top Printer Friendly Version Profile
Search
|
|
|
J_Whitney Moderator Group
|
Joined: November/10/2003 United States Posts: 7413 IP Logged
|
Posted: August/18/2008 at 4:03pm |
Quote
|
|
Lawrence - I put a 2700 MAh NiMH in my Futaba Super 8 and have not regretted it a bit! Charges seem to last forever.
I would caution you to be careful on the peak charge tho - I understand that if the NiMH cells get too hot then you have shortened their life considerably - no more than 10 degrees F over ambient temperature. And you should charge the NiMH at 1C or less, to preserve longevity.
__________________ Jeff
Castro Valley, CA
The essential paradox of our democracy is that our warriors fight and die for our right to dispute the cause for which they are fighting and dying.
Let me know if I can help
|
Back to Top Printer Friendly Version Profile
Search
|
|
|
103/17 Basic Member
|
Joined: September/11/2006 United States Posts: 89 IP Logged
|
Posted: August/18/2008 at 4:22pm |
Quote
|
|
Buy a sirius charge pro and forget about everything you know about charging. They fast charge NiMH batteries all day long and never get hot or overcharge. The microprocessor takes care of it for you. No switches, no calibrations, no polarity issues............they do it all. Check with Dave Thacker at Radical RC hes the one who fixed me up when I switched to 1650 packs in everything I own. These chargers will even fix memory issues with Nicads. I cant say enough good about them. Guys at our field are switching over from whatever they have to the Sirius stuff. Its expensive but its miles ahead of anything else I have used or seen. I dont even charge at home anymore. I only charge at the field.
103/17
__________________ "Democracy is two wolves and a lamb voting on what to have for lunch.
Liberty is a well-armed lamb contesting the vote!"
|
Back to Top Printer Friendly Version Profile
Search
Web
|
|
|
Fighterpilot Site Supporter
|
Joined: September/25/2003 United States Posts: 444 IP Logged
|
Posted: August/18/2008 at 4:42pm |
Quote
|
|
Ditto on the Sirius Charger. I have one that charges two receiver packs and one that will charge one receiver pack and a transmitter pack. Never charge at home anymore and when I'm finished with a couple of flights with my twin 1650 NIMH batteries, I just plug them into the Sirius charger for a quick topping off.
__________________ So many planes, so little time.
Am.Eagle Corsair
Ziroli P-40 sold it
Am. Eagle AT-6 sold it
Hawker Sea Fury
Am. Eagle Spitfire
D/H Mosquito sold it
G/S Mustang
|
Back to Top Printer Friendly Version Profile
Search
|
|
|
HellcatAce Basic Member
Zero Killer
|
Joined: October/13/2005 United States Posts: 42 IP Logged
|
Posted: August/18/2008 at 6:18pm |
Quote
|
|
Agreed re: the issue with careful charging, however, I have a flying buddy who bought a Sirius right from the guy at the AMA show. He was quite sold on the gentlman's claim that their chargers are incapable of creating a memory in NiCd cells. Well, so far he has brought me 2 packs that would not get a good charge from his Sirius. I cycled them on my Hobbico Accu Cycle Elite and was able to bring them back to over 95% capacity. One was NiCd and the other was NiMh.
IMHO for the money he spent on the Sirius charger that is very easy to use, but does not provide any information to the user other than red and green LEDs, he could have spent literally $10 more to get what I feel is a much better charger. I can't attest to the claim of the Sirius charger's ability to "fix" or prevent memory issues in NiCd batteries one way or the other, but I know for sure what the performance of my charger is capable of. When I do cycle my NiMhs occasionaly to test performance, it tells me exactly what the battery's capacity and voltage is so I know it's still performing at it's peak. I have a 1650 NiMh pack with over 150 days of flying on it and it consistently rates at over 100% capacity when I cycle test it.
__________________ Don't try and argue with an Idiot. They just drag you down to their level and beat you with experience!
|
Back to Top Printer Friendly Version Profile
Search
|
|